Following the aroma of simmering herbs and spices while meandering down historic St. George Street, you will soon find yourself greeted by one of our charismatic samplers tempting you to a morsel of gourmet, brick oven pizza. You are welcomed to choose from a list of mouthwatering gourmet slices, or custom create your own piece of heaven with our large variety of freshly prepared toppings!
Escape in the ambiance of our main dining room, or inhale the cool summer nights on our wrap around veranda, everything from our Mussels to Marsalas are sure to make an impression. Oh, and don't forget to save some room for one of our many homemade desserts, such as Tiramisu or Crème Brulee!
Our award winning pizza is only the beginning. For the true Italian food connoisseur, follow our alleyway through our secluded courtyard and enter our full service Italian restaurant. Wine and dine from our extensive wine list, complete liquor bar, and old country entrées, which are sure to please even the pickiest pallet.
For two generations, the Pizzalleys family has pledged to honor our time-tested recipes with the freshest & best quality ingredients. Our "FROM SCRATCH" old fashioned attitude will fill your memory with mouthwatering flavors you will come to savor with each visit... MANGIA! MANGIA!
In the news
Pizzaley's receives National Acclaim
A local favorite was recently recognized for its high-quality food and superior service by one of the food industry’s most-respected organizations.
Pizzalley’s Chianti Room received the National Award of Excellence from the American Culinary Federation in July. It’s one of only 20 restaurants across the country that was selected.